3 Reasons I Hate Personal Brand Statements (But Recommend Them Anyway)

Post image for 3 Reasons I Hate Personal Brand Statements (But Recommend Them Anyway)

by Ryan Rancatore on November 9, 2009

A personal brand statement is a quick blurb that describes your unique focus, experience and expertise. They are hugely popular today. But I must be honest – due to a few common flaws, I’m tempted to suggest not using them altogether. Here are three reasons I dislike most personal brand statements, and why in the end I still encourage you to write one.

1.  Rigidity versus Fluidity

A strong personal brand needs to be flexible and reactive.  As technologies and trends update, so should your personal brand.  I worry that folks with a structured, well-defined personal brand statement will allow outdated features within their personal brand statement to linger for too long.

For an exaggerated example, take “Bob the Beeper Guy”, and his personal brand statement: “Dedicated to delivering premium pagers and beepers to the Southern California business community, with a focus on unparalleled customer service”. At some point in time this statement went from awesome…to awesomely out of date.  I realize this example is a bit extreme.  I also realize we all can change our personal brand statements at any time.  Even still, my worry remains that some folks will blindly become tied to obsolete features of their brand.

"Hi...1993? I'd like my personal brand back, please."

"Hi...1993? I'd like my personal brand back, please."

2. Don’t Tell Me, Show Me

If someone is truly interested to learn what your personal brand is all about, I can promise you this: your personal brand statement isn’t going to fully do the trick. They need to see and feel your brand through your blog postings, portfolios of work, recommendations by clients, etc.  Too often I’ve seen individuals put all their time and effort into crafting the perfect personal brand statement – and they forget that it is the action behind those words that truly matters.

Keep in mind that a personal brand statement should be a quick, inviting prologue – the rest of the story better be damn interesting too!

3. One Size Doesn’t Fit All

In today’s working world, most of us wear many hats.  Maybe you’re like me and have both a day job and an outside passion (that are related, but not identical).  Or maybe you have two roles that are completely different – accountant by day, jewelry designer by night, for example.  How do you address this situation within your personal brand statement?  Will someone looking for custom jewelry care about your accounting expertise?  Doubtful.

With all these negatives, why do I still recommend personal branding statements?  Because sometime, somewhere, you’re going to wish you had one prepared and memorized.  Maybe you will coincidentally meet a venture capitalist or hiring manager in an elevator.  You have 20 seconds until to you reach your floor, and they’ve asked “What do you do?”.  Quick – what is your response?

My unprepared response might be “Um…I, um…I work in the advertising department for a big company.” (Nice, right?)  Now what if I answered instead, “I help businesses and individuals build and promote lasting brands, using the social web as a tool to spark conversation and encourage engagement.” Much better!

So, I suggest that you do write and remember a personal brand statement (or two).  If you decide to do so, here are a few recommended guidelines:

  1. Constantly review your personal brand statement to ensure all qualities and features described within still apply.
  2. Make certain that you “walk the walk”, don’t just “talk the talk”.  Substantiate the claims within your statement, and continually build and improve upon them.
  3. If you own a wide variety of skills and experiences, consider multiple personal brand statements that vary by audience.

For other views on personal brand statements, check out these articles by Dan Schawbel and Brand-Yourself.  What do you think?  Am I being overly critical here?  Care to share your version, or an example of a time your personal brand statement helped you?

Thumbs down by striatic. Bob’s beeper by ePublicist.

Share Across the Web:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Sphinn
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • FriendFeed
  • Google Bookmarks
  • RSS
  • email

Related Posts

  • arthurcharlesvanwyk
    I don't believe one should have a personal branding statement at all.

    At the pace the digital landscape is changing the actual "thing" you do will as well. In 1997 I was a web designer. I was churning out front-end after front-end. The most complicated thing I had to do was insert banner ad code.
    Today what I do goes so far beyond web design. I believe what I do these days is digital marketing, since I have an above average understanding of the medium and what it enables businesses to do online. I outsource all web development and just handle strategy and oversee implementation and the relative timelines.
    Tomorrow I might just see clients, advise on the best possible online solution, recommend a strategy and an agency for implementation and walk away with a cheque.

    My statement would have changed so many times between 1997 and today if I had one.
  • bretsimmons
    Great advice, Ryan. I actually advocate a statement of purpose, which is why you do what you do, not what you do. Your purpose should be steadfast and cover everything you do, even as the things you do change over time. For example, my purpose is to change people's minds about partnering with others to create healthy and responsibile organizations where everyone can thrive. When I started my site, I was not even doing things on personal branding, which is not part of my mission. But helping people develop personal brands is entirely consistent with my purpose because it makes people more flexible and marketable so they can get jobs they love and not have to work for assholes that don't care about them. Keep up the great work! Bret
  • Wow Brett, well said! Do they let you teach that last line in your class?
    ;-) Appreciate the feedback, especially given your experience.
  • bretsimmons
    as a matter of fact, yes. Said it just last night. See, I have this thing about assholes - I hate them! :)
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post: Is Your Personal Brand a Bobblehead?

Next post: Is Personal Branding Overhyped?